Drum Room Construction

Started by beeros05 on 2 February 2012. 135 replies, 2012–2022. In the Library under Build diaries. Key posts in this thread.

Originally posted at johnlsayers.com, topic 17363.

Doors
Image not preserved: IMG_2906.JPG
Image not preserved: IMG_2907.JPG
Image not preserved: IMG_2909.JPG
Image not preserved: IMG_2910.JPG
Image not preserved: IMG_2911.JPG
Image not preserved: IMG_2917.JPG
Image not preserved: IMG_2918.JPG
Image not preserved: IMG_2919.JPG
Nice! Where do you get those doors? Very neat. - Stuart -
Soundman2020 wrote:
Nice! Where do you get those doors? Very neat.
These are custom order Stuart. You can order them from any company with aluminum profiles for doors/windows etc The most important is to order a profile with circumferential sealing mechanism. There are 2 types of this mechanism. One is for security (and more expensive) and the other one is for thermal insulation and sound insulation at the same time. Mine is the second one. The triplex laminated glasses were ordered by the aluminum company after I gave them my specs.
Sound Reduction Measurements OK, so I called a drummer friend of mine, heavy hitter, in order to do some measurements. I used the SPL iPhone app. Here are the results and the Environmental noise 38db. I did the measurements 3m away from the doors. Level Type: Lp Weight: Flat 43db Weight: A 38db Weight: C 43db ------------------------------- Level Type: Leq Weight: Flat 60db Weight: A 50db Weight: C 45db I had no idea how to use it or calibrate it properly
Great! iPhone apps are not very accurate, since the mic and circuitry was never meat to be used for acoustic measurement, and most likely don't cover the necessary part of the spectrum, but at least it will give you some idea of levels. I would go with the "C" weighting: 43 dB outside the room at 3m is pretty darn good! How loud was it inside the room while your friend was playing? It would be very useful to know that, to get a rough idea of how much isolation you are getting.
I had no idea how to use it or calibrate it properly
Just hold it out at arms length, chest height, pointed upwards at an angle. Measurements are normally taken 1m from the wall, door, window, instrument, speaker, mouth. etc. - Stuart -
Soundman2020 wrote:
How loud was it inside the room while your friend was playing? It would be very useful to know that, to get a rough idea of how much isolation you are getting.
I am a heavy hitter, but not for 2 hours...my average measurement where maximum 100db My snare reaches 110db But these numbers are average. I am around 90+ db
OK, so assuming your buddy was playing typically, and your snare hits 110, then lets' call his level 110 (conservatively). So, 110 inside, 43 outside.... That's 67 dB of isolation! :!: Stand up and take a bow! :yahoo: That's pretty darn good, in anyone's book. Better than I expected. Even assuming that the iPhone app is very inaccurate, and off by 10 dB, 57 dB is still really, really good, and something to be proud of. Remember way back here, on page 3, you said you wanted 70 dB but didn't think you could get it, and I said that it was possible if you worked very carefully, but that even 60 would be more reasonable? viewtopic.php?f=2&t=17363&start=23 Looks like you got your wish, and beat my expectations! :) In fact, you have achieved the "holy grail" of home studio building: effectively isolating a drum kit, in a small room, and it still sounds good inside! You can't hear it, but I'm applauding! :) When you have finished the final details of the room and posted the photos of that, I'm going to ask John to make this thread into a "sticky", as it is a shining example of the correct way to build a drum room. - Stuart -
Soundman2020 wrote:
Even assuming that the iPhone app is very inaccurate, and off by 10 dB, 57 dB is still really, really good, and something to be proud of.
Why are iPhone apps inaccurate? Because they are "apps" or because of the built in mic? There are apps that you can use external mic. So maybe I should find a way to connect a mic with my iPhone, what type of mic should i use?
Soundman2020 wrote:
In fact, you have achieved the "holy grail" of home studio building: effectively isolating a drum kit, in a small room, and it still sounds good inside!
Yeap, sth like this... I have noticed since I installed the doors that the bass drums sound MUCH better! Why is that happening?
Soundman2020 wrote:
I'm going to ask John to make this thread into a "sticky", as it is a shining example of the correct way to build a drum room.
Good idea, and thats because this "case study" is not only "what to do" but also "what NOT to do" :P You cant see me, but Im laughing :yahoo: I recall one year ago these days...I was so unhappy and disappointed and now I can play 24/7 !!! And here comes the BEST part... I bought a Zoom R16 Recorder / USB Interface and a used MacBook with Logic Pro and a set of budget mics. The interface is pretty good, value for money product, but still doesnt have very good preamps. The mics are also "budget" I have started recording and mixing 2 months now, I am very newbie. I called some friends, sound engineers, to hear some mixings of mine. FLAT, no EQ, compressions etc. They couldnt believe what they were hearing! One of them told me to use my room for his drum recordings :shock: When I find a job and get some money I'll buy better mics and a MOTU Interface...
Why are iPhone apps inaccurate? Because they are "apps" or because of the built in mic?
The mic is not an omni with flat response from 20 Hz up to 8kHz, it cannot handle very loud sounds without clipping, and the pre-amp is not meant for acoustic work either. It is a very cheap mic on a very cheap pre-amp.
There are apps that you can use external mic. So maybe I should find a way to connect a mic with my iPhone, what type of mic should i use?
Well, you could do that, yes, with an external mic and pre-amp..... but you'd spend more money than by just buying a meter on e-bay or Amazon.com! A decent meter costs around US$ 75 - 100 (don't go for the ultra-cheap US$ 25 Chinese junk), and that is NEW! You can often find used ones for about US$ 50 or so.
I have noticed since I installed the doors that the bass drums sound MUCH better! Why is that happening?
I'm not 100% sure, and just guessing here mainly, but I suspect that it's because the room is now air-tight with the doors closed, so that is keeping the very low frequency pressure in: so the room is "pumping" now, with the low frequency over-pressure from each kick hit, instead of that over-pressure being able to "leak" out through the doors. Just a guess... Do you have both heads on the kick? Does the front head have a hole in it, for the mic? In general, I find that in small rooms, drums sound better with the front head removed, or at least with a decent sized hole for mic'ing. Also, how are you mic'ing the kick? It depends on the mic and the sound you are looking for, but I find that a good place for the mic is about 2" away from the back head, a bit below the spot where beater hits the head, and pointing right at that spot. That's where I normally start with mic'ing the kick, then move it around a bit to see if I can improve on that. Mic'ing drums is part science, part art.... Everyone has their own technique!
I bought a Zoom R16 Recorder / USB Interface and a used MacBook with Logic Pro and a set of budget mics. The interface is pretty good, value for money product, but still doesn't have very good preamps. The mics are also "budget"
Is that what you used to record the You-Tube track? If so, that's not too bad at all. Sounds quite decent, actually. - Stuart -
Beeros have you finished the overall construction? Can you upload some pictures for us?
You guys did a great job! But I'm just wondering: What is the purpose of this build? Do you need to isolate the room so that your drums can't be heard outside? Or are you trying to keep out some noise from the outside?
Read the thread from the start: it's all explained in the posts. - Stuart -
Hi there!!! Looong time!! I finished the studio and installed electrics, ventilation and air-condition!!
Image not preserved: IMG_0125.jpg
Image not preserved: IMG_0126.jpg
Image not preserved: IMG_0127.jpg
Image not preserved: IMG_0115.jpg
Congratulations!!!! :thu: :yahoo: :yahoo: :yahoo: A long hard road, but you finally got there! I'm glad we were able to help you out a bit along the way. This is actually one of my favorite threads!!!! - Stuart -
I just realized that I had forgotten to make this thread a "sticky"! So I just fixed that: it is now a sticky, which it deserves to be! Are you still smiling, Beeros? I sure hope you are now enjoying your completed room, and playing LOTS of drums in there... 24/7! :shot: :shot: :shot: :shot: :yahoo: :shot: :shot: :shot: :yahoo: :shot: :shot: :shot: :yahoo: - Stuart -
Good to see that you have such a great place to work in Beeros. You deserve the credit since you made all the right decisions. And now this thread may stand for a long time and be read by many, many others and you can teach them with your efforts. Good luck,
VERY INSPIRING! memorised everything i need to do, and not do. saving this for later, thanks for the experience! :shot:
Soundman2020 wrote:
Congratulations!!!! :thu: :yahoo: :yahoo: :yahoo: A long hard road, but you finally got there! I'm glad we were able to help you out a bit along the way. This is actually one of my favorite threads!!!! - Stuart -
xSpace wrote:
Good to see that you have such a great place to work in Beeros. You deserve the credit since you made all the right decisions. And now this thread may stand for a long time and be read by many, many others and you can teach them with your efforts. Good luck,
Thank you everybody, I am so grateful to ALL of you! The credits belong to you guys and the forum. Here are some more pictures Drumkit
Image not preserved: 20150318_205756.JPG
Mixer Front
Image not preserved: 20150318_205648.JPG
Mixer Back
Image not preserved: 20150318_205657.JPG
Panoramic Action Cam
Image not preserved: 20150318_205927.JPG
Side Monitor for Recording Alone
Image not preserved: 20150318_205939.JPG
Our band sign...Mr. Bones on a bass trap!
Image not preserved: 20150318_205933.JPG
Now the drum multi-cable... I bought a 24 line Belden multi (the "studio" quality version) stripped it and made my 12Line Multi with heat shrinkable tubes. The extension of the cables from the ends of the tubing until the plugs were put into smaller plastic tubes that are used for the garden automatic watering for extra protections. The rest of the lines were put into plastic tubes and we made extra cables for speakers monitors guitars, pedals etc.
Image not preserved: 20150318_210036.JPG
Image not preserved: 20150318_210042.JPG
The Studio
Image not preserved: 20150318_210220.JPG
Finally a Video with multitrack recording! We played with the Canadian Thrashers RAZOR, 2 weeks ago and this video is from our rehearsals preparing for the Gig. It is Live Recording we are rehearsing the song "Breakout" from the band's second album "Raw n Filthy". Drum Mics are the Senheiser's e-600 Series Pack. Recorded and mixed with Logic Pro X. Guitar, Bass and Vox are LINE. Drums are stripped silenced and I triggered the snare only with Drumagog 5. I used Logic's Preset EQ Rock Toms, Rock Kicks and another EQ Preset for the Overheads. Guitar Rig "Straight Metal" Preset (sth like that) for the Guitar Line and for the Bass Line the DI Bass Preset also from Guitar Rig https://youtu.be/EQjwgl7mzXg
Hi, what I perceive and judge that this room is quite small and difficult to accommodate so many musical equipments inside it...and so far you want perfect isolation and non-reverberation so that a good sound quality can be produced without disturbing the people in surrounding area...as same sort of problem I faced in past and I took help from [SPAM LINK DELETED BY MODERATOR] who made me satisfied and they have very talented and laborious staff who can do anything...however you can take assistance of some good planner or constructor who can sort out this problem completely....
Kevin Young wrote:
Hi, what I perceive and judge that this room is quite small and difficult to accommodate so many musical equipments inside it...and so far you want perfect isolation and non-reverberation so that a good sound quality can be produced without disturbing the people in surrounding area...as same sort of problem I faced in past and I took help from [SPAM LINK DELETED BY MODERATOR] who made me satisfied and they have very talented and laborious staff who can do anything...however you can take assistance of some good planner or constructor who can sort out this problem completely....
And what I perceive is that you are nothing but a lousy spammer, who did not bother reading even one single word of this thread! Therefore you will be banned and blocked if you don't man up and prove your claims. In reality, this room is one of the best isolated studios on the entire forum, which is already full of many, many well-isolated rooms, all of which are vastly superior to what might be expected of a third-rate urban-planning outfit with no background in studio design. This room provides absolute isolation from the people in the surrounding areas (as you would know if you would have bothered to read the thread). Even those right outside cannot hear the bad at all. If you really did have this same problem in the past, and if an "urban planning" organization really did "satisfy" you, then please do go ahead and document that studio build in your own thread. We will be happy to critique it for you... 8) Finally, Beeros actually did "take assistance of some good planner", meaning all of us here on the forum who gave him solid, sound, precise acoustical advice, which he then used to build this excellent place... as you would know if you bothered to read the thread! And we already did "sort out this problem completely" ... as you would know if you bothered to read the thread! Now either provide the proof that substantiate your claims, or shut up. And either way, stop harassing people like Beeros who have done an outstanding job building their rooms, and stop hijacking the threads of other people with your inane "advice". - -
I just read this thread in it's entirety & I gotta say I'm really glad I did! I have dyslexia & it took me 4 & a half hours to get through it all. I'm amazed at everyone who contributed to this thread. You all have an amazing amount of patience, especially taking into factor the culture barriers that exist. I've learned a TON!
That was like reading a good book. Start to finish you all had me on the edge of my seat. Good verses evil, the heart break and then victory. Nice job Beeros, congrats
I started a tutorial about insulation and construction BASED on my story It is in Greek but it is subtitled in English https://youtu.be/04rL3fjPcFc I hope you enjoy it!
Very nice Spiros! Finally, a YouTube video about isolating a room, that is correct and truthful about the acoustics. There's a couple of problems with the soundtrack on your video, though: at 5:33 there's a sudden surge in the background music that drowns out your voice, at 5:43 it sounds like have the sound from a porn movie(!), at 6:15 there's the sound of someone knocking loudly on a door, and at 6:24 and 6:44 there's a very loud motorbike that drowns your voice. In general, maybe you could turn down the backing music a bit, as it overwhelms your voice in most of the video, and is distracting: It's great music, but the level is a bit high for background. I was thinking that you could add a few diagrams to illustrate what you are talking about with MSM and several of the other concepts, as well as some photos of your original (failed) construction, then also of the final one that worked. Maybe also pictures of the actual sound level readings from your meter, inside and outside, to show the real results. I know this is just part 1, and you will show that in the other parts, but it make make it more interesting to have some images in the introduction, so your viewers can get an idea of what you will be detailing in the rest of the series. Thanks for listing the forum in the credits! Feel free to put a link in there to your thread as well: that might be very interesting for your viewers. I'm looking forward to seeing the rest! - Stuart -