Starting Fresh and Obeying the Laws of Physics

Started by edenorchestra on 25 November 2004. 51 replies, 2004–2005. In the Library under Walls, floors and ceilings.

Originally posted at johnlsayers.com, topic 2718.

Last month Steve wrote this:
knightfly wrote:
. . . your badly damaged original floor could be leveled with gypsum joint compound before adding a layer of gypsum (I'd use the "greenboard" version of gypsum, made for bathrooms, etc, since this is a floor and possible wetting may happen from mopping, etc) - then, I'd put a solid layer of MDF or OSB on top of the gypsum. . . (Source)
However, last year he wrote this:
knightfly wrote:
I'm not a fan of using particle board as a bottom layer of floors that are over concrete - moisture and particle board aren't a good combination - also, if you're going to float the entire room on top of this floor, I'm not sure if using a sandwich of gypsum in the floor is a good idea either - I've not done this, and I'm a bit leary of that much weight pressing down on a particle board and gypsum floor without compression problems. (Source)
So, I think the answer may depend on whether or not you're floating your walls on it. :roll:
Those were my thoughts as well . . I am indeed floating the walls and that would cause too much compression . . . I will pass on that idea . . .