Automatic Door Closers

Hi All, I have four doors I need closers for. Each door will consist of a 1-3/4" thick solid core door with a 1" MDF slab attached to it. Would these products work? Are they overkill? Do you have any closers you can recommend. Thank you! Howie https://www.amazon.com/Commercial-Aluminum-Compliant-Lawrence-Hardware/dp/B06Y3P92NP https://www.amresupply.com/part/13-1900BFDAAL-BARRIER-FREE-DELUXE-CLOSER

Both look good to me! Greg