For the speaker stands would I be ok using ... stands on them?
Well, I suppose you could if you don't mind spending a lot of money on items of questionable performance... On the other hand, for a few bucks you could put some tried-and-proven Sorbothane pads under the speakers, and get excellent isolation.
Those fancy stands would not solve the issue of lack of mass. Stand need to be MASSIVELY heavy. Some people stack up concrete blocks, others use hollow stands filled with sand. Right now, I'm working with a customer in the USA who is building his stands from 1/4" steel pipe... not that the pipe is 1/4" diameter, but that the steel
itself is 1/4" thick! The pipes are 6" diameter, welded to a 1/2" steel plate base, and with a steel grid shelf on top for the speaker. That too will be sand filled. Sorbothane pads both under the entire thing, and also under the speaker. Overkill, perhaps, but he certainly has the right idea! Those speakers will be absolutely isolated and very well decoupled from the floor...
That's what I mean by massively heavy.
:)
Or should I rebuild them with maybe 1.25-1.5" MDF
Something just a little heavier would be in order...
:)
- Stuart -