particleboard vs stave core

Started by groundhog on 30 October 2009. 1 reply.

Originally posted at johnlsayers.com, topic 13734.

anyone know which type of door core is better for screwing on a layer of 5/8'' drywall and 3/4'' plywood with green glue between layers? i've read that stave core doors have much better screw holding strength and resistance to warping, but would i need them in my case? the price difference is pretty big - $350 per stave core door and $195 per particleboard core door.
groundhog wrote:
i've read that stave core doors have much better screw holding strength and resistance to warping, but would i need them in my case?
You read wrong, as a general guideline. The difference on if a door has a solid wood interior or a composite interior doesn't control the ability of the door to hold a screw or not, nor does it affect the doors susceptibility to warp age. Moisture content in the wood and the environment on both sides of the door will play a bigger part in that. A solid core [composite interior], fire rated door has less susceptibility to warp age then does a shop made stave and veneered door. The screw being used has to be designed to go into a dense material, either with a pilot hole (pre-drilled) or a self piloting screw designed for wood. Sheetrock screws will almost always snap off somewhere before being half-way installed and fully seated. Either door is dense enough to do the job.